For the next few months Brenda Hill will dash from fundraiser to festival, from organizing volunteers to public speaking events and from the campaign office to school board meetings as the newest member.
“I’m excited more than nervous,” Hill said. “I really am proud of the school system and there is always room for improvements to make.”
The Toledo Public School Board members appointed Hill, a retired teacher and a candidate for November’s election, to the vacant seat on the school board on June 20.
Board member Darlene Fisher, the only member who voted no to Hill’s appointment, said she did not vote for Hill’s appointment because she’s running in November’s election.
“I think for those who supported her it gives her an edge up — already serving on the board,” Fisher said. “Of the three seats available in November, I am the only incumbent running for re-reelection; the other two have been appointed. Now we have two appointees and one person who is there for the people.” She added that President Bob Vasquez was also appointed to the board, rather than voted on.
She nominated Carolyn Eyer, who runs day care at Bible Temple Family Worship, because Eyer understands how to work with the zero to eight year-old range, Fisher said, adding that she thinks the school board needs to focus on that age group more.

Brenda Hill
Vice President Lisa Sobecki, who nominated Hill, said she didn’t make decisions based on whether the 11 applicants were running for reelection because the filing deadline for candidacy isn’t until August. If she had chosen someone because they didn’t plan on running and the appointee changed his or her mind after getting appointed, it wouldn’t be fair to other applicants, Sobecki said.
Chris Myers ran for a school board seat twice and lost, but also applied for the vacant seat. He said he had no intensions of running in the upcoming election and also stated that he would donate the money he would receive as a board member right back to the school district.
“One of the things that’s going to hurt her, is that not only is going to have to get oriented with board but she’ll have to run for election,” Myers said. “The problem is that you’ll have three board members running for election so they won’t be able to put all the time into the board as needed.”
Hill said she is ready to take on the work, and that her experience as a teacher for 35 years can help her truly understand all the different areas affected by the board’s decisions.
However, the 35 years as a teacher worries Fisher and Urban Coalition member Steven Flagg, they said.
The board has a contract with the Toledo Federation of Teachers that expires on March 31, and if no one tries to change any of the conditions of the contract the students will suffer and schools will continue to fail state tests, Flagg said.
Fisher also said that she didn’t vote for Hill because she was once a member of the TFT and this background could persuade her to make decisions based on the union’s agenda.
Citing that the union allows for more experienced teachers to bid for schools further away from the city and with fewer problems, Fisher said she would want to offer payment incentives for skilled teachers to stay in the inner-city.
“There’s an assumption here when we talk about who’s endorsed by the TFT that this labor union is not interested in what’s best for the students,” said school board President Bob Vasquez. “I don’t agree with that; it would be like saying that Save Our Scott or the Urban Coalition is not interested in what’s best for their students and I don’t think that’s fair do say that about these groups.”
Flagg said he thinks the TFT has guided board members to side with them on issues that do hurt the kids, and not requiring teachers to assign homework to suspended children is one of those.
Though the number of suspensions and expulsions has been decreasing, with 390 total students getting expelled in the 2008 to 2009 school year, Fisher said she would want to change the clause about not requiring homework for suspended kids.
“What we’ve seen happen is that a child starts out with a behavior problem and if they don’t get the help they need their career goes down and down,” Fisher said. “I want to make sure we avoid this so teachers are required to provide homework.”
Fisher, as the only member not endorsed by the TFT, said funding elements need to change as well, and having TFT endorsed members keeps that from happening.
Of the $320 million budget, 75 percent is spent on salaries and 25 percent is spent on materials and maintenance, Fisher said.
“I think we have to take good care of our teachers because they have the right to have good working conditions if they are happy, it’s obvious that our students will benefit from the same type of environment,” Vasquez said.
Fisher said she’s not opposed to the union and wants to give teachers a fair amount of funding; she just wants to reconsider how programs in the schools are funded. Anticipating August’s 2008 to 2009 state grade card for the district, she said schools will not change if the current contract remains the same – and having board members like Hill backed by the TFT would face that ‘conflict of interest’ when voting for the contract in March.
Hill said she will make decisions independently from the TFT.
“If I don’t agree with the union or not; whether who agrees with me or not is not my concern,” she said. “I’ve been chosen to represent the city of Toledo and my allegiance is to them.”
Hill graduated from Rogers High School, received a bachelors and masters degree from University of Toledo and taught a few different district schools during her 35 years of employment. Her home school was Navarre Elementary, where she taught remedial math, though she also spent time teaching computer skills to other teachers, she said.
There she had to help kids in elementary school learn basic skills because they hadn’t gone to preschool or came from homes where the parents had no time to spend with them, she said. Hill retired in 2004.
Hill said she wants to make foreign language classes part of the curriculum and that she would negotiate with the board and the TFT, if elected, in March when the contract expires to make changes if needed.
Sobecki said Hill has the experience and organizational skills to take the seat.
“Yes, she is a retired teacher of 35 years,” Sobecki said. “But she also has the working knowledge of the class room and an understanding of the district and with August right around the corner and the first day of school issues facing the board, she would be a fast learn and could be brought to speed quickly.”
After former City Council President Mark Sobczak resigned and Council member Joe McNamara took his place, council appointed former TPS Board President Steven Steel to take McNamara’s seat. Hill will take Steel’s spot for the next four months.